Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Where Do The Lakers Go From Here?

One Less Day Til Football Season 2010, Post 9: Northwestern's Safeties

Who saw that Northwestern is now ranked No. 12 by the US News and World Report. The only BCS programs ranked higher are Stanford and Duke. And neither of them have blogs on SB Nation. Which means... I AM THE SMARTEST BLOGGER ON THESE HERE INTERNETS. I ORDER ALL OF YOU TO COMMENCE DEALING WITH IT.

If you don't mind, I'll be off to work on getting my cumulative GPA higher than that of the average football player. (not joking) (although I'm off by a very very small amount)

Days Left Til Football Season: 17 (Damn!)

One Less Day Til Football Season, Post 8: Safety

Star-divide

Who did it last year?: Well, son, the preeminent starters were Brad Phillips (at free safety) and Brendan Smith (at strong safety). They were each multi-year starters and therefore, we sort of knew what we were getting. Brad Phillips was going to hit people as hard as he could, and Brendan Smith could do good things too. However, both guys got injured a little bit. Brian Peters actually spent nearly half of the season subbing in for Smith, earning five starts and picking off three passes - more than the entire starting unit. Which is especially impressive, considering he played with a cast on his right hand. Him and Jared Carpenter actually started the Indiana game. Although safety was touted as one of the team's better units because of all the experience and spectacular plays we'd seen from Phillips and Smith - the Minnesota game interception return from Smith, the Shonn Greene hit from Phillips - injuries and whatnot kept this unit from being overwhelmingly consistent. 

Who's got next?: There's no incumbent starters, but there doesn't seem to be much of a battle for the starting spots: Peters will definitely start after playing well last year, and Carpenter seems to have his gig locked down. That's because there's a frightening lack of depth at the safety spot on the roster. The next most experienced player is David Arnold, who was prominent as a starter at linebacker, but suffered a foot injury in week 1 of training camp that will apparently put him out until past the opener, giving a scary opening to  what could a very productive season from him. After him, there's Hunter Bates, who has primarily played on special teams, and is best known for a) having the same number and physical appearance as Dan Persa and b) recovering an onside kick against Illinois, and Davion Fleming and Scott Lilja, two guys who have never played snaps featuring NUsports.com bios saying that if all goes well, they will be important factors in the kicking game. Basically, it's on Peters, Carpenter, a potentially healthy Arnold, and Bates - and we don't know what we'll be getting out of Carpenter, Arnold, or Bates.

Is that an improvement?: I suggest you re-read the last sentence of the previous paragraph. Here, I'll write it again. Basically, it's on Peters, Carpenter, a potentially healthy Arnold, and Bates - and we don't know what we'll be getting out of Carpenter, Arnold, or Bates. The only mitigating factor here is that I feel we had an understandable tendency to overrate NU's safeties the year before because they were experienced and likable, so the dropoff here isn't as big as it might seem. But it's a major dropoff. Peters seems like he'll be a menace in pass coverage, and Carpenter hopefully can step up and hit people. But this could be the dagger our defense doesn't need.  

Comment 6 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

I'd be more concerned with the CBs...

Peters should be able to step in just fine for Smith.

Carpenter at least has some experience, and the coaching staff is very high on him in camp. Again, hopefully he can do a respectable job.

IF anyone gets injured, that is when I would start to worry. Bates has talent but precious little experience. Beyond that, there is basically nothing. Hopefully the law of averages will help NU avoid injury (particularly at this position) since that is the biggest weakness.

In terms of the starters, I would be more worried about the CBs than the safeties, though.

--
JHodges
HailToPurple

by jhodges on Aug 18, 2010 9:13 AM CDT reply actions  

Health is what I’m concerned about. I don’t think the starters will be a huge dropoff at either safety or corner considering how banged up the starters were last year. However, if that happens again…

by NUHighlights on Aug 18, 2010 9:38 AM CDT up reply actions  

cosign

we had injuries at both safety spots, which means the play we got wasn’t as great or consistent as it could’ve been. in fact, it lost us some games. the fact that there were there last year injuries make this better in two ways: first off, the dropoff won’t be as severe as we act like it might. secondly, the guys playing for us got serious experience last year.

by Rodger Sherman on Aug 18, 2010 12:15 PM CDT up reply actions  

Not too worried...

…safety is a position where you tend to be able to plug in a sub and have them play well/adequately….plus, I think Carpenter has enough experience to be good (didn’t he get some Outback Bowl snaps?), and I think Arnold might be back by the time Big Ten season rolls around (I hope)….

by Chadnudj on Aug 18, 2010 9:23 AM CDT reply actions  

I went to the #1 liberal arts college on the US News and World thing

high-five for the innerwebs smartest blogging tandem!

by Loretta8 on Aug 19, 2010 1:09 PM CDT reply actions  

actually

according to forbes, you went to the best overall school in the nation. you probably should go start your own blog. i’m holding you back.

by Rodger Sherman on Aug 19, 2010 3:57 PM CDT up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Because hip-hop references and Northwestern athletics go together like small academic institutions and gynormous athletic powerhouses.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Mask_small
Chicago's Finest
Mask_small
Super Important Spring Soccer Games
Small
Big Ten Basketball - 2012/2013
Mask_small
Defending B1G Champion NU Men's Soccer Spring Preview
Small
Recruiting Comparison
Small
Crawford should declare for NBA Draft
Small
Can I get everyone on the record about Carmody?
Small
Chris Collins
N1086180148_30136552_2108_small
The Carmody Post
Dscn0025_small
Bid Stealing Update, March 8

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Managers

30956_1404928997786_1069228069_1222854_7361661_n_small Rodger Sherman

Editors

Small Loretta8

Authors

Small Herman